Running pants and shorts have become a top-selling category on Amazon US in 2024, driven by growing demand for stylish, comfortable, and functional activewear. To uncover what matters most to buyers, we analyzed thousands of customer reviews from the five best-selling products. This report highlights key patterns in what users appreciate—like comfort, fit, and stretch—and what common issues they encounter, such as transparency or durability. The goal is to provide retailers and product teams with clear, data-backed insights into consumer preferences in this fast-moving category.
Table of Contents
Individual Analysis of Top Sellers
Sinophant High Waisted Leggings With Pockets
CRZ YOGA Butterluxe High Waisted Leggings
Walifrey High Waist Leggings With Pockets
The Gym People Thick High Waist Yoga Pants With Pockets
Campsnail 4 Pack High Waisted Leggings
Comprehensive Analysis of Top Sellers
What do customers who buy this category want to get most?
What do customers dislike the most?
Conclusion
Individual Analysis of Top Sellers
To understand what makes a product stand out in a competitive category, we examined customer feedback on the five best-selling running pants and shorts. Each product reveals distinct strengths and recurring issues based on real user experiences. The following section breaks down what buyers loved—and what left them disappointed—for each top seller.
Sinophant High Waisted Leggings With Pockets
Introduction to the Item:
The Sinophant high waisted leggings are designed as affordable, full-length yoga pants made of a soft polyester and spandex blend. They feature a wide waistband that offers gentle tummy control and two side pockets for added practicality. Marketed as stretchy, squat-proof, and breathable, the leggings cater to women looking for everyday comfort, whether for workouts or lounging. The fabric is advertised as “buttery soft,” aiming to mimic the feel of more premium activewear brands at a fraction of the cost. These leggings are available in multiple sizes and colors, making them accessible to a broad customer base. With over 4,000 reviews and the #1 spot in their category, they are clearly a top-selling item on Amazon.
Overall Analysis of the Comments:
With an average customer rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars, the Sinophant leggings are generally well received by buyers. Positive reviews commonly cite the fabric’s comfort, stretchiness, and flattering fit as reasons for their satisfaction. Many users reported purchasing multiple pairs, noting that these leggings quickly became a go-to item in their wardrobes. However, a consistent thread among more critical reviews pointed to concerns with material thickness, especially in lighter colors. Some also expressed a desire for better long-term durability. Overall, these leggings strike a strong balance between value and wearability, especially for casual or low-intensity use.
What Aspects of This Product Do Users Like the Most?
Customers consistently describe the leggings as exceptionally soft and stretchy, comparing them favorably to far more expensive brands. The high waistband earns praise for staying in place and providing a smoothing, flattering silhouette without discomfort. The two side pockets are frequently highlighted as a practical and well-integrated feature, large enough to hold smartphones securely. Many users enjoy the versatility of the leggings, wearing them for yoga, errands, or even sleep. The product’s affordability is another commonly mentioned advantage, especially for multi-pack purchases. In short, the leggings deliver reliable comfort and style for a very reasonable price point.
What Flaws Did Users Point Out?
Some buyers noted that the fabric can be overly thin, particularly in brighter or lighter shades, leading to concerns about transparency. A few reviews mentioned that the leggings became see-through during workouts or deep stretches. Durability was another recurring issue, with minor pilling or stitching problems reported after several washes. The fabric also tends to attract pet hair and lint, which was a nuisance for customers with animals at home. Taller users or those with more athletic builds sometimes found the leggings too short or tight around the thighs. Finally, a few customers wished for firmer compression to better support high-impact activity.
CRZ YOGA Butterluxe High Waisted Leggings
Introduction to the Item:
The CRZ YOGA Butterluxe high waisted leggings are a premium option designed to rival top-tier activewear brands. Made with the brand’s signature Butterluxe fabric, they offer a smooth, silky texture and four-way stretch. These leggings feature a seamless waistband and are available in multiple lengths and sizes. They’re intended for low to medium-intensity workouts, as well as casual or all-day wear. The minimalist design, soft hand-feel, and performance fabric make them a favorite among comfort-seeking consumers.
Overall Analysis of the Comments:
The CRZ YOGA leggings enjoy a strong average rating of 4.6 out of 5, reflecting high customer satisfaction across hundreds of reviews. Shoppers consistently describe the leggings as a “Lululemon dupe” and praise the close feel of the Butterluxe fabric. Comfort is a standout theme, with many users saying they forget they’re even wearing them. Fit accuracy is another frequently mentioned strength, with customers saying the size chart is reliable and consistent. While the leggings are on the higher end of Amazon’s pricing scale, many believe the quality justifies the cost. Most negative feedback was minor and related to specific preferences rather than major product flaws.
What Aspects of This Product Do Users Like the Most?
Many users were impressed by the feel of the Butterluxe fabric, often described as “buttery soft” and smooth against the skin. The leggings’ ability to stay in place during both intense workouts and daily wear was also highly praised. Several reviewers appreciated the simple, elegant design with minimal seams and no front seam, reducing the risk of camel toe. Buyers also mentioned the leggings’ flattering compression and contouring effect around the waist and hips. Color consistency and fabric thickness received positive mentions, especially among buyers who ordered multiple pairs. Overall, the product exceeded expectations for those seeking quality activewear at a reasonable price.
What Flaws Did Users Point Out?
Some users felt the leggings lacked strong compression, making them less ideal for high-intensity workouts or running. There were occasional comments about the fabric being slightly slick, which made them ride down during certain exercises like squats. A few reviewers found the waistband to be less supportive than expected, especially for postpartum or plus-size wearers. In rare cases, customers reported pilling after several washes, although this was not widely observed. Some color variants were noted to be more sheer than others, particularly in direct light. Finally, the price was seen as a drawback by budget-conscious shoppers, despite the quality.
Walifrey High Waist Leggings With Pockets
Introduction to the Item:
The Walifrey high waist leggings are positioned as a budget-friendly choice for women seeking soft, stretchy leggings for casual wear and light workouts. They feature a high waistband for mild tummy control and functional side pockets for carrying small items. The fabric is a polyester-spandex blend, designed to be breathable and lightweight. These leggings are offered in a range of sizes and solid colors, making them accessible to a broad audience. Their marketing emphasizes softness, comfort, and everyday wearability over athletic performance.
Overall Analysis of the Comments:
The Walifrey leggings have earned an average rating of 4.3 out of 5 from more than 2,000 buyers, indicating generally positive customer sentiment. Many users praised the fabric’s soft, buttery texture and found the leggings ideal for lounging or low-impact exercise. Reviewers often commented on the usefulness of the pockets, which comfortably fit phones and keys. Buyers were also attracted to the low price and noted the leggings offered good value for everyday use. However, some users raised concerns about long-term durability and fit consistency. Despite these drawbacks, the product remains a popular choice in the budget leggings category.
What Aspects of This Product Do Users Like the Most?
Buyers frequently described the fabric as soft, light, and gentle against the skin, ideal for relaxed settings like yoga or home wear. The waistband received positive feedback for staying up without digging in or causing discomfort. Many users highlighted the deep pockets as both functional and surprisingly secure for holding phones or cards. The price point was a major selling factor, especially for those purchasing multiple pairs. Customers also appreciated the simple styling and color options that made the leggings easy to match. Overall, the product’s comfort-to-cost ratio was a key driver of repeat purchases.
What Flaws Did Users Point Out?
Several users mentioned that the leggings were thinner than expected, especially in lighter colors, raising concerns about sheerness. There were reports of the fabric stretching out or showing wear quickly, particularly after machine washing. A few buyers noted stitching defects or seams coming loose within a few uses. Some found the sizing inconsistent, with certain colors fitting more snugly or loosely than others. Others felt the leggings lacked the compression or firmness needed for gym workouts or running. While many users were satisfied for casual wear, they generally did not recommend them for high-performance use.
The Gym People Thick High Waist Yoga Pants With Pockets
Introduction to the Item:
The Gym People high waist yoga pants are designed to offer a balance between performance and comfort, targeting users who need more support during workouts. These leggings are made with a thick, squat-proof blend of polyester and spandex, with moisture-wicking and four-way stretch properties. They feature a wide waistband for tummy control and two side pockets for convenience. The design emphasizes both form and function, making them suitable for gym training, running, and everyday wear. Available in multiple sizes and colors, they aim to serve both fitness-focused and casual consumers.
Overall Analysis of the Comments:
With an average rating of 4.4 out of 5, these leggings are widely appreciated for their support and functionality during workouts. Many reviewers praised the thickness of the fabric, which helped them feel secure and fully covered during squats and stretches. Comfort and breathability also stood out, with buyers saying the leggings stayed cool and dry even during extended sessions. The waistband was frequently described as firm but comfortable, contributing to a flattering fit. While many customers were satisfied with the product’s durability, a few mentioned stitching issues over time. On the whole, feedback reflects a reliable choice for women who prioritize both support and aesthetics.
What Aspects of This Product Do Users Like the Most?
Reviewers consistently highlighted the leggings’ thick, supportive fabric as ideal for both gym and home workouts. The waistband drew compliments for providing reliable tummy control without rolling down or digging in. Many buyers appreciated that the fabric remained opaque under strain, giving them confidence during squats or lunges. The side pockets were praised for their size and stability, easily fitting larger phones. Customers also liked the contoured fit and flattering design, which enhanced body shape without being too tight. Several buyers said the product compared well to more expensive brands in terms of feel and performance.
What Flaws Did Users Point Out?
Some users found the waistband slightly too compressive, especially for casual wear or long lounging periods. A number of reviews mentioned minor stitching flaws or seam fraying after several months of use. A few customers said the fabric retained heat during intense cardio, making them feel warm or sweaty. There were also complaints about inconsistent sizing across colors or batches, particularly with small and medium sizes. A handful of buyers reported that the leggings lacked stretch in the lower legs, causing a restrictive feel. Despite these issues, most agreed the leggings performed well for their price and purpose.
Campsnail 4 Pack High Waisted Leggings
Introduction to the Item:
The Campsnail 4 pack high waisted leggings are designed for value-conscious shoppers who want multiple pairs of basic leggings at an affordable price. Each set includes four full-length leggings made from a polyester-spandex blend, featuring a high-rise waistband for mild tummy control. The product is marketed for daily wear, lounging, and light exercise rather than high-performance sports. It targets users seeking comfort and quantity over technical features. With a focus on softness and stretch, the product appeals to buyers looking to stock up on everyday essentials.
Overall Analysis of the Comments:
With an average rating of 4.4 out of 5, the Campsnail leggings set has received strong praise for comfort, value, and versatility. Many users were impressed by the softness of the fabric and the wide, comfortable waistband. The fact that the product includes four pairs at a low price was repeatedly mentioned as a major advantage. Customers often wore them for lounging, casual outings, or as underlayers during colder months. While they were not positioned as athletic wear, several buyers still found them adequate for light yoga or walking. Overall, the product met or exceeded expectations given the price.
What Aspects of This Product Do Users Like the Most?
Buyers frequently praised the price-to-quantity ratio, with many stating they didn’t expect such good quality from a four-pack. The fabric was described as soft and stretchy, offering a “barely there” comfort ideal for daily use. The high waistband was appreciated for staying in place without digging in or rolling down. Many reviewers liked the color variety and simplicity of the design, which made the leggings easy to mix and match. Customers also noted that the leggings retained their shape well after washing. Several said they were pleasantly surprised and intended to repurchase the pack.
What Flaws Did Users Point Out?
Some users mentioned that the fabric was quite thin, making the leggings unsuitable for squats or workouts where opacity matters. A few reviews noted that the material wore out quickly, especially between the thighs after regular use. There were also complaints about inconsistencies in sizing, with some pairs fitting tighter or looser than others within the same pack. A handful of buyers found the waistband lacked support for larger body types or postpartum needs. Others reported minor stitching issues, such as threads loosening after a few washes. While not disqualifying, these flaws suggest the leggings are better suited for comfort than performance.
Comprehensive Analysis of Top Sellers
What do customers who buy this category want to get most?
Customers place a high value on comfort, often describing their ideal leggings as soft, breathable, and “barely there.” The feel of the fabric against the skin is repeatedly mentioned, with phrases like “buttery soft” or “cloud-like” dominating positive reviews. This desire for comfort is especially strong among buyers who wear leggings for extended periods, whether at home, at work, or during travel. Products like CRZ YOGA and Walifrey have excelled in this regard, offering lightweight fabrics that do not irritate the skin. Customers expect to feel unrestricted during movement, whether stretching or sitting. A legging that feels comfortable instantly becomes a staple in their wardrobe.
Another top priority is waistband functionality, particularly high-rise designs that provide a secure, flattering fit. Customers want waistbands that stay in place without rolling down or causing discomfort, even during movement. Many reviewers mentioned postpartum support or tummy control as key benefits of a well-constructed waistband. Brands like The Gym People and Sinophant scored highly for offering snug but gentle compression around the midsection. Additionally, shoppers value that the waistband can enhance their shape without being overly tight. It’s not just about control—it’s about feeling confident and supported throughout the day.
The presence of side pockets has gone from a “nice-to-have” to a non-negotiable feature in this category. Customers frequently mention using pockets to carry smartphones, keys, or cards during errands or workouts. Pockets that lie flat and don’t add bulk are preferred, especially in leggings that double as casual or travel wear. This feature enhances the versatility of the product and has a noticeable impact on purchase decisions. Many buyers compare leggings with and without pockets and show a clear preference for the former. Even budget-focused consumers like those buying Walifrey or Campsnail expect this level of utility.
Lastly, value for money is a consistent driver of customer satisfaction, whether in single pairs or multi-pack options. Customers are highly responsive to leggings that outperform their price point in comfort, fit, and durability. For example, Sinophant leggings are repeatedly described as “better than expected” for the price, while Campsnail earns praise for offering four solid pairs at a fraction of premium brands’ cost. Buyers want the assurance that they’re not sacrificing quality for affordability. This doesn’t necessarily mean the lowest price wins—it means delivering on expectations relative to cost. Perceived value fuels loyalty and often leads to repeat purchases.
What do customers dislike the most?
One of the most consistent complaints is thin or see-through fabric, especially when stretched during bending or workouts. Even leggings marketed as “squat-proof” sometimes fail in lighter colors or under bright light. Customers are quick to criticize any lack of opacity, as it directly impacts usability in public or gym settings. Several buyers mentioned feeling uncomfortable or embarrassed after noticing sheerness mid-use. This issue is particularly prevalent in value-focused products like Walifrey and Campsnail. The absence of sufficient thickness leads to trust issues and negatively affects the overall rating.
Another major frustration lies in inconsistent sizing, both within multi-packs and across color variants. Buyers expect sizing to be standardized, but many report that different colors or batches of the same product fit differently. This inconsistency forces customers to size up or down unpredictably and increases return rates. It also creates hesitation around repeat purchases, even when the first pair fit well. Products like Campsnail and Walifrey were especially prone to this issue based on review patterns. When sizing isn’t reliable, customers feel let down by the brand’s quality control.
Durability concerns also appear frequently, particularly for leggings under $20. Users complain of pilling, loose threads, or stretched-out waistbands after only a few washes. These issues are not exclusive to the lowest-cost items—some mid-range products also receive complaints if construction isn’t up to par. Many buyers expect leggings to last at least several months of regular use and become frustrated when performance drops early. Washing care is often cited in complaints, with delicate fabrics requiring hand-washing or air drying to preserve quality. When longevity doesn’t match expectations, it reflects poorly on perceived value.
Lastly, customers dislike lack of compression and support, especially those using leggings for fitness or body contouring. Leggings that feel too loose or lacking in hold are described as “baggy,” “unsupportive,” or “like pajamas.” Buyers who are active or plus-size often require more structural support around the waist and thighs. Products like Sinophant and Walifrey occasionally fall short here, especially in one-size-fits-most models. Some users also pointed out that insufficient compression made the leggings ride up or shift during movement. Compression isn’t always about tightness—it’s about feeling secure and confident during wear.
Conclusion
Our analysis of Amazon’s top-selling running pants and shorts in the US shows that customers care most about comfort, a secure high waist, and practical features like side pockets. Products that balance softness, fit, and value earn the highest praise, while common complaints include thin fabric, inconsistent sizing, and poor durability. Whether premium or budget, shoppers expect leggings that feel good, perform reliably, and justify their price. For brands, meeting these core needs is essential to winning in this competitive, review-driven category.
