Running tights have become a staple in both athletic and casual wardrobes across the U.S., praised for their comfort, versatility, and performance-enhancing features. With a surge in popularity among fitness enthusiasts and everyday wearers alike, Amazon’s top-selling running tights reveal much about consumer preferences and expectations. In this blog, we delve into thousands of customer reviews from the platform’s five bestsellers, offering a data-driven analysis of what users truly value—be it fabric quality, fit, durability, or functionality. By exploring both the highlights and common drawbacks noted in real-world feedback, we aim to provide actionable insights for retailers and product developers in this highly competitive category.
Table of Contents
Individual Analysis of Top Sellers
GAYHAY High Waisted Leggings for Women
THE GYM PEOPLE Thick High Waist Yoga Pants with Pockets
Bluemaple Women’s High Waisted Leggings – 4-Pack
G Gradual Men’s Sweatpants with Zipper Pockets
AUROLA Seamless High-Waisted Workout Leggings for Women
Comprehensive Analysis of Top Sellers
What do customers who buy this category want to get most?
What do customers who buy this category dislike the most?
Conclusion
Individual Analysis of Top Sellers
To understand what drives customer satisfaction in the running tights market, we examined user feedback on five of Amazon’s top-selling products in the U.S. Each product offers a unique blend of features, from compression support to casual comfort, tailored to different user needs. Below is a detailed breakdown of how each item performs based on thousands of verified customer reviews.
GAYHAY High Waisted Leggings for Women
Introduction to the item
The GAYHAY High Waisted Leggings are designed for all-day wear, combining affordability with versatility. Marketed as ultra-soft, breathable, and stretch-friendly, they are made from a blend of 92% polyester and 8% spandex. These leggings feature a high waistband for a snug fit and are commonly used for light workouts, yoga, lounging, and layering under clothing. Their appeal lies primarily in comfort-focused design and budget-friendly pricing, making them especially popular among casual users rather than performance-focused athletes.
Overall analysis of the comments (Rating: 4.3 out of 5)
With an average rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars, the GAYHAY leggings maintain strong favorability across a wide range of users. Customers frequently describe them as “comfortable,” “soft,” and “lightweight,” often recommending them for indoor wear, errands, or low-impact activities. While many reviews affirm that the leggings fit true to size and feel like a second skin, others highlight variability in fabric thickness across different color options. The product’s lower price point is often cited as a significant advantage, allowing customers to buy multiple pairs without stretching their budgets.
What aspects of this product do users like the most?
Customers overwhelmingly praise the softness and comfort of the fabric, noting its gentle texture against the skin. The high waistband is another frequently appreciated feature, offering a secure and flattering fit without digging into the waist. Flexibility and stretch also earn high marks, particularly for users with varied body shapes and sizes. Many users mention they are ideal for lounging or casual outings, with minimal rolling or slipping during daily wear. For budget-conscious shoppers, the leggings deliver solid value, often outperforming expectations based on price alone.
What flaws did users point out?
The most common criticism centers around the fabric’s thinness—some customers find it too sheer for confident public use, especially in lighter colors. A few reviewers report issues with breathability when used during workouts, suggesting that the material may retain heat or moisture. Additionally, there are sporadic complaints about stitching quality and fabric pilling after multiple washes, which affects long-term durability. While marketed as multipurpose, these leggings are not perceived as ideal for high-intensity exercise or outdoor running.
THE GYM PEOPLE Thick High Waist Yoga Pants with Pockets
Introduction to the item
THE GYM PEOPLE’s Thick High Waist Yoga Pants with Pockets are a popular choice among fitness enthusiasts looking for function and form. Constructed from a blend of 88% polyamide and 12% spandex, these leggings are designed with four-way stretch and moisture-wicking technology, making them suitable for workouts, yoga, running, and casual wear. Key features include a wide high-rise waistband for tummy control, reinforced seams for durability, and most notably—deep side pockets for storage convenience. The design balances compression with comfort, aiming to provide a flattering, supportive fit for active users.
Overall analysis of the comments (Rating: 4.3 out of 5)
Maintaining a solid average rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars, these leggings are frequently praised for both their appearance and practicality. Many reviewers highlight the leggings’ squat-proof performance and smooth, firm feel, which supports moderate to intense exercise without discomfort. The inclusion of pockets is consistently described as a standout feature, offering enough room for essentials like phones or keys during workouts. Reviewers commonly report that the fabric holds up well after washing, and that the leggings retain their shape and color over time.
What aspects of this product do users like the most?
Users consistently commend the leggings for their high-quality fabric and strong, supportive compression. The fit is described as flattering, especially due to the high waistband that helps smooth the midsection without rolling down. Pockets on both thighs are widely celebrated for their practicality—many customers consider them indispensable for gym or on-the-go use. Shoppers also note that the material is thick enough to avoid transparency, giving them the confidence to wear the leggings in public and during exercise. The true-to-size fit and consistent quality across orders also boost customer confidence in repeat purchases.
What flaws did users point out?
Despite largely positive feedback, some users reported that the sizing can feel inconsistent—particularly in colored variants, which may fit more snugly than black or gray versions. A few reviews mention that the waistband can feel overly tight or rigid, especially when worn for extended periods. Although the material is moisture-wicking, it may still feel heavy during high-sweat workouts, limiting breathability. Some users experienced pilling after repeated washes, especially when the leggings were machine dried. Lastly, customers with very curvy or tall body types occasionally found the length or rise slightly off, resulting in a less-than-perfect fit.
Bluemaple Women’s High Waisted Leggings – 4-Pack
Introduction to the item
The Bluemaple High Waisted Leggings come in a budget-friendly 4-pack, appealing primarily to shoppers looking for everyday comfort and variety. Made from a blend of 92% polyester and 8% spandex, these leggings emphasize stretch, softness, and lightweight wear. With a 4.5-inch wide waistband and squat-proof claims, they are designed for casual workouts, home wear, and layering. Available in a wide size range (S/M to 4X), the Bluemaple leggings aim to be an inclusive, practical choice for women seeking both style and functionality in bulk.
Overall analysis of the comments (Rating: 4.1 out of 5)
These leggings earn an average rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars, supported by praise for value and comfort. Customers often mention being pleasantly surprised by the quality relative to the low price, especially when purchasing for loungewear or casual use. The multipack format is frequently highlighted as a major convenience, allowing buyers to rotate through leggings throughout the week without repeated laundering. Many reviews praise the softness and stretch of the fabric, though some signal a clear boundary between casual use and high-performance fitness.
What aspects of this product do users like the most?
The standout praise goes to the comfort and feel of the fabric—described as buttery soft and lightweight, making them ideal for relaxing at home or layering under longer tops. Many users consider the waistband to be supportive without constriction, and report that it stays in place without rolling. The generous stretch accommodates a wide range of body types, and the availability of inclusive sizing is positively received. The affordability of receiving four pairs at once is repeatedly cited as a value win, with many customers purchasing multiple packs.
What flaws did users point out?
The most frequently noted issue is transparency—some users find that lighter colors are see-through, particularly when bending or under bright light. A number of customers also report that these leggings lack sufficient compression for fitness activities, making them less ideal for running or gym workouts. Durability concerns arise in some reviews, with mentions of fabric pilling, seam unraveling, and color fading after several washes. Additionally, while marketed as squat-proof, experiences vary depending on body type and color selection. Finally, customers expecting a firm or athletic fit often express disappointment, noting that the leggings are better suited for casual wear.
G Gradual Men’s Sweatpants with Zipper Pockets
Introduction to the item
The G Gradual Men’s Sweatpants are athletic joggers designed with a tapered leg fit and three secure zippered pockets. Made from a lightweight, breathable fabric blend, these pants are marketed for a wide range of uses—from gym workouts and running to everyday wear and travel. With features like a flexible waistband, three-way stretch fabric, and reinforced stitching, these joggers aim to balance functionality, comfort, and modern styling. Though technically joggers, they compete in the same space as running tights for male consumers prioritizing comfort and flexibility during physical activity.
Overall analysis of the comments (Rating: 4.1 out of 5)
With a steady average rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars, these sweatpants earn consistent praise for comfort, fit, and multi-purpose usability. Reviewers frequently highlight the zippered pockets as highly functional for securing phones, wallets, and keys—especially during movement-heavy activities. Customers also appreciate the fabric’s softness, moderate warmth, and quick-dry capabilities. Many note they wear the joggers beyond workouts, including to the office, while traveling, or lounging, emphasizing their versatility.
What aspects of this product do users like the most?
Comfort and fit are the most celebrated aspects—users describe the pants as lightweight yet substantial, with a soft touch that’s ideal for sensitive skin. The stretch and elasticity of the fabric enable ease of motion, particularly appreciated by those who bike, jog, or perform dynamic workouts. Zippered pockets are repeatedly mentioned as a major plus, offering secure storage that prevents belongings from falling out during runs or gym sessions. The tapered cut is viewed as stylish and flattering, suitable for casual or semi-athletic aesthetics. Many users also commend the pants for maintaining their fit and finish after washing.
What flaws did users point out?
While generally well-received, taller users (over 6’1”) often find the pants too short in length, leading to fit concerns around the ankles. A few customers mention inconsistent sizing between different color variants or production batches. There are occasional reports of seam issues—such as minor unraveling after minimal use—raising questions about long-term durability. Some reviews express dissatisfaction with the high waistband rise, which may feel awkward for users with shorter torsos. Finally, although functional, these joggers are not always ideal for high-intensity training where tighter compression or muscle support is preferred.
AUROLA Seamless High-Waisted Workout Leggings for Women
Introduction to the item
AUROLA’s Seamless High-Waisted Workout Leggings are part of the brand’s “Intensify Collection,” designed for high-performance fitness, yoga, and everyday wear. Made from a blend of 56% nylon, 34% polyester, and 10% spandex, these leggings are constructed with four-way stretch fabric that emphasizes compression, flexibility, and a flattering contour. Key design features include a reinforced gusset for movement freedom, a wide high-rise waistband for tummy control, and a seamless build to reduce chafing. Marketed as both functional and stylish, these leggings cater to active women who prioritize fit, lift, and shape enhancement.
Overall analysis of the comments (Rating: 4.2 out of 5)
With an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars, AUROLA leggings receive widespread praise for their flattering fit and performance-focused design. Many customers compare them to high-end brands like Alphalete and Gymshark, noting that they offer similar contouring effects at a more accessible price point. The leggings are described as squat-proof in darker colors, maintaining full opacity under stretch. Users also appreciate that they maintain their structure over time without excessive shrinkage or sagging, especially when air-dried.
What aspects of this product do users like the most?
Customers consistently highlight the flattering sculpted fit, particularly around the waist and glutes. The seamless design and scrunch detail at the back enhance body shape without the discomfort of pronounced stitching or ruching. The compression level is widely appreciated for gym workouts and lifting routines, offering both support and freedom of movement. The leggings are also lauded for their durability, with many users stating they hold up well after months of use and repeated washing. Additionally, the variety of available colors and inclusive sizing options help appeal to a broader audience.
What flaws did users point out?
Despite their strengths, AUROLA leggings are not without drawbacks. One frequently mentioned issue is sizing inconsistency, with several users recommending to size up—especially for those between sizes or with athletic builds. Some customers report that the fabric tends to pick or pill, particularly in high-friction areas, affecting the sleek appearance over time. While many colors are squat-proof, lighter shades may still become slightly transparent under tension or bright lighting. Additionally, although the leggings offer good stretch, some users noted a lack of breathability during intense cardio sessions, making them more suitable for strength training than long runs.
Comprehensive Analysis of Top Sellers
What do customers who buy this category want to get most?
Buyers of running tights on Amazon U.S. are driven by a need for apparel that performs seamlessly across fitness, casual, and everyday use. Across all five top-selling products, customers frequently highlight the importance of comfort—particularly in the form of soft, stretchy fabrics and secure high-waisted designs. Waistbands that stay in place during movement and provide moderate tummy control, like those in AUROLA and THE GYM PEOPLE leggings, are especially valued for their ability to flatter and support. Flexibility is another major theme; consumers expect the material to move with their bodies, not restrict them, and leggings like those from G Gradual and AUROLA deliver on this expectation through four-way stretch construction.
Additionally, the growing demand for practicality is clearly reflected in customer praise for leggings with functional pockets. THE GYM PEOPLE and G Gradual sweatpants stood out for their zippered or side pockets that securely hold phones, keys, or cards—features that significantly enhance real-world utility, especially for users on the go. Another high-priority trait is opacity. Many users emphasize the importance of leggings being “squat-proof” and not see-through, which influences whether they feel confident wearing them in public, particularly at gyms. Lastly, customers continue to seek strong value for money. Products like Bluemaple, which come in economical multi-packs, fulfill this by providing adequate comfort and basic function at a low cost, appealing especially to casual users or those purchasing in bulk for routine wear.
What do customers who buy this category dislike the most?
Despite overall positive ratings, customer reviews consistently identify several recurring issues that impact satisfaction. One of the most frequently mentioned drawbacks is the problem of transparency in lighter-colored leggings. Shoppers expressed frustration when leggings marketed as opaque turned out to be see-through under stretch or certain lighting, a concern raised particularly with Bluemaple, GAYHAY, and select AUROLA shades. This not only undermines product trust but limits their use in more public or active scenarios where discretion matters.
Sizing inconsistency is another widespread complaint. Across several products, including AUROLA and G Gradual, users noted differences in fit between color variants or experienced unpredictable sizing outcomes despite following charts. This is especially problematic in leggings, where a slight variation can drastically affect comfort and function. Similarly, some leggings—especially the softer, more casual ones like Bluemaple and GAYHAY—were found to lack compression or shaping support, making them less suitable for workouts despite being marketed for fitness. Many customers expected a more structured, supportive feel for running or gym use and were disappointed by the overly relaxed fit.
Durability also emerges as a concern. In more affordable options like GAYHAY and Bluemaple, reports of pilling, seam separation, and fading after just a few washes are common. Even premium-feeling products like AUROLA are not immune to wear issues, particularly with picking or snags in the fabric. Lastly, breathability challenges are noted, especially with thicker materials used in THE GYM PEOPLE and G Gradual sweatpants. Though warm and supportive, these fabrics may trap heat and moisture during cardio-heavy sessions, making them more appropriate for strength training or cooler environments rather than high-sweat, high-motion activities.
Conclusion
In summary, Amazon’s top-selling running tights in the U.S. reveal a market shaped by customer demand for comfort, versatility, and practical design. Shoppers consistently prioritize features like high-waisted fits, stretchable and soft fabrics, and functional elements such as pockets and squat-proof opacity. While affordability remains a strong driver—especially for casual wear options—performance expectations are rising, particularly around durability and consistency in sizing. The most successful products are those that strike a balance between activewear functionality and everyday comfort, offering flattering fits without compromising on quality or usability. For retailers, the takeaway is clear: delivering reliable, well-fitting, and multifunctional leggings will resonate most with today’s increasingly discerning buyers.
