Button making machines have seen a surge in popularity, becoming a must-have tool for crafters, hobbyists, and small business owners alike. With a variety of options available on Amazon, it can be challenging to choose the best one. To help make this decision easier, we analyzed thousands of customer reviews for the top-selling button making machines in the US.

This comprehensive review highlights what users love about these products, the common issues they face, and which machines stand out in terms of performance, ease of use, and value for money. Read on to discover the key insights from real users’ experiences and find the perfect button maker for your needs.

Table of Contents
Individual analysis of top sellers
Comprehensive analysis of top sellers
Conclusion

Individual analysis of top sellers

VEVOR Button Maker Machine 2.25 inch/58mm Pin Maker

Introduction to the item

The VEVOR Button Maker Machine 2.25 inch/58mm Pin Maker is a versatile and sturdy tool designed for crafting high-quality buttons. It is particularly popular among hobbyists, small business owners, and event organizers due to its robust construction and reliable performance. This machine is capable of producing buttons of 2.25 inches (58mm) in diameter, making it ideal for a variety of applications, from promotional items to personalized gifts.

Overall analysis of the comments

The VEVOR Button Maker Machine has garnered a significant number of positive reviews, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars. Customers frequently commend its solid build and ease of use. Many users report that the machine produces professional-quality buttons consistently, which has contributed to its high rating.

What aspects of this product do users like the most?

1. Sturdy and reliable build quality: Users appreciate the machine’s durable construction, which ensures long-term use without significant wear and tear. “The 1.25 button machine is very sturdy despite being lighter than other models,” one user noted.
2. Easy to use and set up: Many reviews highlight the machine’s user-friendly design, which makes it accessible even for beginners. One customer mentioned, “This is a great product. It was pretty easy to figure out and works well.”
3. High-quality button production: The machine’s ability to produce professional-looking buttons is a major selling point. A satisfied user shared, “I bought this expecting that I would ruin the first few buttons, but it worked perfectly!”

What flaws did users point out?

1. Some units arrived with missing or damaged parts: A few users reported receiving their machines with minor defects, such as missing washers or scratched surfaces. One review stated, “This item arrived scratched and missing a washer, but it still worked well.”
2. Initial learning curve for optimal use: While the machine is generally easy to use, some customers experienced a learning curve in mastering the button-making process. A user advised, “Took a bit of practice at first. What I discovered is that practice makes perfect.”

This detailed breakdown of the VEVOR Button Maker Machine 2.25 inch/58mm Pin Maker provides a clear picture of its strengths and areas for improvement, helping potential buyers make an informed decision.

Button Maker Machine Multiple Sizes 1-1.25-2.25in

Introduction to the item

The Button Maker Machine Multiple Sizes 1-1.25-2.25in is a versatile tool designed to cater to a wide range of button-making needs. It offers the flexibility to create buttons in three different sizes: 1 inch, 1.25 inches, and 2.25 inches. This feature makes it particularly appealing for crafters, educators, and small business owners who require varying button sizes for different projects.

Overall analysis of the comments

This button maker has received positive feedback from users, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars. Customers appreciate its versatility and the quality of buttons it produces. The machine’s multi-size capability is frequently highlighted as a significant advantage, allowing users to diversify their creations.

What aspects of this product do users like the most?

1. Versatile size options for different projects: Users love the flexibility of making buttons in multiple sizes. One reviewer mentioned, “It’s my first attempt at making my art into buttons, and I love that I can make different sizes.”
2. Great customer service: Many users have praised the company’s customer service for being responsive and helpful. A satisfied customer wrote, “BEST CUSTOMER SERVICE. They were quick to respond and very helpful with my questions.”
3. Fun and engaging for various activities: The machine is often used in fun and interactive settings, such as community events and craft nights. A user shared, “We used this at a community event, and everyone loved making their own buttons.”

What flaws did users point out?

1. Instructions could be clearer: Several customers found the provided instructions to be confusing or insufficient. One user commented, “The printed instructions were clear as mud, but the machine itself is very straightforward once you get the hang of it.”
2. Issues with specific parts like fasteners: Some reviews mention problems with particular components, such as the fasteners. A user noted, “Everything about these was great until I went to assemble the buttons. The backing made the fastener almost impossible to attach.”

This in-depth analysis of the Button Maker Machine Multiple Sizes 1-1.25-2.25in highlights its versatility and user-friendly design, while also pointing out areas where improvements could be made to enhance user experience.

800 PCS Button Maker Supplies, 58mm/2.28 inch

Introduction to the item

The 800 PCS Button Maker Supplies kit includes everything needed to create a large number of 2.28 inch (58mm) buttons. It is designed for use with compatible button making machines and is ideal for individuals and organizations needing to produce buttons in bulk. The kit includes button shells, mylar covers, and pin backs, providing a comprehensive solution for large-scale button production.

Overall analysis of the comments

The 800 PCS Button Maker Supplies kit has received a mix of reviews, with an average rating of 4.0 out of 5 stars. Customers appreciate the value for money and the quantity of supplies included. However, there are some concerns regarding the quality of the materials and durability of the finished buttons.

What aspects of this product do users like the most?

1. Good value for money with lots of supplies: Customers frequently highlight the cost-effectiveness of the kit. One review stated, “For the price, you get a lot of supplies, which makes it a great deal.”
2. Works well once set up correctly: Users find that the supplies work effectively with their button machines when properly assembled. A satisfied customer noted, “The cost-effectiveness is great, considering how many buttons you can make with this set.”
3. Ideal for large-scale production: The kit is praised for its suitability for bulk button making. One user mentioned, “Good value for the money, but be prepared for some minor issues with certain components.”

What flaws did users point out?

1. Quality of materials could be better: Several customers reported issues with the durability and quality of the materials, particularly the mylar covers and button backs. A review stated, “Beware of Mylar. It started peeling off after a few weeks of use.”
2. Issues with durability over time: Some users found that the buttons did not hold up well over time. One reviewer commented, “The buttons looked great initially, but the quality degraded quickly.”
3. Problems with specific parts: A few reviews mentioned defects in the backing or fasteners, making the assembly process difficult. A user shared, “The backing made the fastener almost impossible to attach.”

This comprehensive review of the 800 PCS Button Maker Supplies kit highlights its strengths in terms of value and quantity while also addressing common quality issues that potential buyers should be aware of.

VEVOR Button Maker Machine, 1-1.25-2.28 inch (25-32-58mm)

Introduction to the item

The VEVOR Button Maker Machine, capable of producing buttons in three different sizes (1 inch, 1.25 inches, and 2.28 inches), is designed for versatile use. This machine is ideal for crafters, educators, and business owners who need to create buttons of various sizes for different projects. Its multi-size functionality makes it a popular choice for users seeking flexibility and efficiency in their button-making endeavors.

Overall analysis of the comments

The VEVOR Button Maker Machine has received generally positive feedback, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars. Customers praise its ease of use, versatility, and consistent performance. Despite some reported issues, the machine’s ability to produce high-quality buttons in multiple sizes is highly valued.

What aspects of this product do users like the most?

1. Reliable performance: Users appreciate the machine’s consistent ability to produce high-quality buttons. A satisfied customer stated, “This is a great product. It was pretty easy to figure out and works well.”
2. Easy to use and versatile: The machine’s user-friendly design and multi-size capabilities are frequently mentioned as key benefits. One review highlighted, “1.25 button machine is very sturdy despite being lighter than other models.”
3. Versatility for different projects: The ability to make buttons in three sizes is a significant advantage for various applications. A user noted, “Having multiple sizes available makes this machine perfect for all my crafting needs.”

What flaws did users point out?

1. Some units have alignment issues: A few users reported difficulties with the machine’s alignment, affecting the quality of the buttons produced. One review mentioned, “Had trouble with the machine’s alignment, making it hard to produce quality buttons.”
2. Mixed reviews on customer service: While many users found the customer service helpful, others experienced challenges in getting support. A user shared, “Customer service was very responsive and helped me resolve my issue quickly,” while another noted, “Didn’t get the help I needed when I encountered problems with the machine.”

This detailed analysis of the VEVOR Button Maker Machine, 1-1.25-2.28 inch (25-32-58mm), showcases its versatility and user-friendly design, along with some areas where improvements could enhance the user experience.

Button Maker Machine 58mm (3rd Gen) Installation-Free

Introduction to the item

The Button Maker Machine 58mm (3rd Gen) Installation-Free is designed for ease of use, requiring no assembly. This machine is ideal for both beginners and experienced users, providing a hassle-free button-making experience. Its 58mm size is perfect for creating large, eye-catching buttons for various purposes, including crafts, promotional items, and personal projects.

Overall analysis of the comments

The Button Maker Machine 58mm (3rd Gen) Installation-Free has received high praise from customers, boasting an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Users highlight its simplicity, efficiency, and high-quality output. The installation-free feature is particularly appreciated, making it accessible and convenient for all users.

What aspects of this product do users like the most?

1. No installation required, easy to start using: Customers love the convenience of the installation-free design. A reviewer mentioned, “Included: Button Maker (pre built), large allen wrench, and all the supplies. It’s super easy to use.”
2. Great for high-volume button making: Users appreciate the machine’s ability to produce large quantities of buttons quickly and efficiently. One user shared, “I got this today, and made 177 buttons. LOVE THIS!”
3. High-quality button production: The machine consistently produces professional-looking buttons, which is a significant advantage for many users. A satisfied customer stated, “I’ve been making some pretty cute pins for Etsy, and they sell out fast.”

What flaws did users point out?

1. Some units arrived in poor condition: A few customers reported receiving their machines with defects such as scratches or missing parts. One review noted, “This item arrived scratched and missing a washer, but it still worked well.”
2. Initial hesitation due to price: Some users were initially hesitant to purchase the machine due to its price, but found it to be worth the investment. A user commented, “At first I was hesitant to buy this button maker because of the price, but it’s definitely worth it.”

This in-depth analysis of the Button Maker Machine 58mm (3rd Gen) Installation-Free highlights its ease of use and high efficiency, while also addressing some minor concerns related to product condition and initial cost.

Comprehensive Analysis of Top Sellers

What are the top desires of customers?

Ease of Use and Quick Setup

1. Minimal Assembly Required: Users highly value button makers that require little to no assembly. Machines like the Button Maker Machine 58mm (3rd Gen) Installation-Free are particularly appreciated for their ready-to-use design. Comments like “super easy to use” and “installation-free, ready out of the box” are common praises.
2. User-Friendly Instructions: Clear and concise instructions are crucial for a positive user experience. Products with straightforward setup guides and simple operational procedures receive higher ratings. For instance, many customers of the VEVOR Button Maker Machine 2.25 inch/58mm Pin Maker highlighted its easy setup process.

Versatility and Multiple Size Options

1. Ability to Make Various Sizes: The flexibility to produce buttons in multiple sizes is a major selling point. Machines like the Button Maker Machine Multiple Sizes 1-1.25-2.25in are favored for their ability to cater to different needs. Reviews often mention, “Love that I can make different sizes,” highlighting the importance of versatility.
2. Adaptability for Different Projects: Customers appreciate machines that can be used for various types of projects, from small personal crafts to large promotional events. This adaptability is crucial for users who want to maximize the utility of their button maker.

High-Quality Output

1. Professional-Looking Buttons: The ability to produce high-quality, professional-looking buttons consistently is a top priority. Users frequently mention the excellent output quality of machines like the VEVOR Button Maker Machine, emphasizing phrases like “buttons look professional” and “high-quality button production.”
2. Durability of Buttons: Customers look for machines that produce durable buttons that can withstand regular use without falling apart. Reviews highlighting the “sturdy build” and “long-lasting buttons” are indicators of customer satisfaction in this regard.

What do customers dislike the most?

1. Product Defects and Quality Issues

Arrival in Poor Condition: A common complaint among users is receiving products with defects such as scratches, missing parts, or misalignments. Reviews often note, “item arrived scratched” or “missing components,” which can lead to initial disappointment and a need for replacements.

Quality of Materials: The durability and quality of the materials used in the button making process are frequently scrutinized. Issues like “mylar peeling off” and “backing made the fastener almost impossible to attach” are mentioned, indicating areas where manufacturers can improve.

2. Initial Learning Curve

Complexity in Initial Use: Despite being generally easy to use, some button makers have a learning curve that frustrates users initially. Comments like “took a bit of practice” and “initial learning curve” suggest that while the machines are effective, better instructional materials could enhance the user experience.

Confusing Instructions: Poorly written or unclear instructions can significantly hinder the user experience. Customers of the Button Maker Machine Multiple Sizes 1-1.25-2.25in mentioned, “printed instructions were clear as mud,” indicating a need for better guidance.

3. Customer Service Challenges

Inconsistent Customer Support: While many users report positive experiences with customer service, others find it lacking. Reviews such as “customer service was very responsive” contrasted with “didn’t get the help I needed” highlight the inconsistency in customer support experiences across different products.

4. Durability Concerns

Longevity of the Product: Customers expect their button making machines to last and perform well over time. Complaints about durability, such as “buttons didn’t hold up over time,” suggest that some products may not meet long-term expectations. Enhancing the durability of both the machines and the buttons they produce could address these concerns.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the analysis of customer reviews for the top-selling button making machines on Amazon reveals that ease of use, versatility in size options, and the ability to produce high-quality, professional-looking buttons are the most valued features by users. While these machines generally receive positive feedback, common issues such as product defects, initial learning curves, and inconsistent customer service highlight areas for improvement. By addressing these concerns, manufacturers can enhance customer satisfaction and reliability. Potential buyers should weigh these insights to select a button maker that best fits their needs, ensuring a rewarding and efficient button-making experience.